In a study driven by simulation modeling, researchers elaborated on policies that contribute to widening health disparities affecting Indigenous communities.
Funding reform can help address policy-driven inequities directly impacting Indigenous-led community-based organizations’ (ICBO) sustainability, according to a recent study published in Health Affairs.
Generational trauma experienced by Indigenous people has disproportionally influences the state of their psychosocial well-being. The authors argue that these impacts are upheld and exacerbated by racist and inequitable systems that create toxic cycles hindering the types of care that can be offered in these communities.
ICBOs can deliver culturally based care that, in turn, can be more effective and beneficial to Indigenous people than forms of Westernized standard practice.
"ICBOs also are able to build stronger authentic relationships with community members compared to larger public, nonprofit, or private institutions with ongoing legacies of racial mistreatment," the authors noted.
However, there are a wealth of obstacles ICBOs face in their efforts to provide essential services to alleviate the psychosocial concerns in their communities. Primarily, the authors point to funders’ policies around grants and regulation that are incompatible with ICBOs’ needs and contribute to structural inequities furthering Indigenous oppression.
As a consequence of the funding, grant, and regulatory system, ICBOs often find themselves stuck in what is known as a “capability trap.” A capability trap is another term for identifying a short-term solution that is administered at the expense of long-term growth. These applied “quick fixes”—here, regarding funding—make it progressively harder for ICBOs to meet various goals or address unmet needs in their organization or community. Furthermore, as the authors mention, these policies and short-term solutions uphold the success of bigger, White-led institutions that hold the most power in the realm of psychosocial care.
To model these issues, researchers used a systemic dynamics methodology. In total, 148 members of a small community in the Northern Great Plains region participated and built visual diagrams to represent the underlying funding issues affecting the problematic, complex systems they exist in. Fifty percent of these participants were Indigenous and their models were further enhanced through discussions with Indigenous community partners (coauthors). These coauthors had experience in providing psychosocial care through ICBOs and navigating the private, public, and Tribal systems they encounter.
The models identified 6 key challenges related to funding policies that impact ICBOs:
A common route ICBOs take to avoid the strain from these issues comes in the form of subcontracted partnerships. In these instances, an ICBO may form a relationship with a larger, non-Indigenous organization that does not face these barriers for securing funding. While these partnerships can enable ICBOs to receive adequate funding and offer effective, culturally based care, these relationships intrinsically form a hierarchy. The larger organization will continue to have control over funding and ICBOs can end up dependent on their partners and forced to endure drawbacks such as funding delays.
To confront these ongoing issues, the authors call for funders to address their indirect cost rates, include grants intended for building infrastructure and capacity, and reform what qualifies as a direct service to better accommodate Indigenous communities. They also argue that competition between ICBOs for limited grants causes lots of strife in these organizations and worsens the funding issues they encounter. Some solutions to this problem could include a multi-ICBO care grant or a shift in grant focus towards how ICBOs collectively benefit their communities.
Additionally, minimizing the obstacles ICBOs face for seeking and managing grants could help them obtain the resources they require to not only sustain themselves, but also grow to address the unmet psychosocial needs in their communities.
"Unique contexts for Indigenous communities, characterized by both oppression and cultural strength, require distinct consideration," the authors concluded. "Investing in Indigenous self-determined health requires changing the investment process from top-down provisional structures to bottom-up growth and empowerment of Indigenous communities."
Reference
Deutsch AR, Frerichs L, Hasgul Z, et al. How funding policy maintains structural inequity within indigenous community-based organizations. Health Aff (Millwood). 2023 Oct;42(10):1411-1419. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2023.00483.
Enhancing Outpatient Hemophilia Care May Improve Health Outcomes and Costs
May 18th 2024Prospective data from patients attending a rural practice in West Virginia between 2016 and 2023 show that a quality improvement program that followed guideline recommendations and was tailored to specific patient needs reduced preventable bleeds and lowered costs.
Read More
Health Equity and Access Weekly Roundup: May 18, 2024
May 18th 2024The US Senate hosted a panel addressing physician and health care shortages and efforts to increase minority representation in the medical field. An expert discussed initiatives to prevent senior homelessness. Advocates called for the repeal of the Comstock Act. Regulatory reforms are called for to improve rural cancer patients' access to pharmacies. Research reveals the impact of denials on patient access to immunology treatments.
Read More
Frameworks for Advancing Health Equity: Urban Health Outreach
May 9th 2024In the series debut episode of "Frameworks for Advancing Health Equity," Mary Sligh, CRNP, and Chelsea Chappars, of Allegheny Health Network, explain how the Urban Health Outreach program aims to improve health equity for individuals experiencing homelessness.
Listen
Congress Urged to Repeal Comstock Act Threatening Reproductive Rights and Public Health
May 16th 2024In a joint letter addressed to Congress, Healthcare Across Borders, Take Back the Court Action Fund, and UltraViolet Action called out the resurgence of the Comstock Act, urging immediate action to repeal this century-old law that threatens reproductive rights and public health in the US.
Read More
After the ACA Expanded Health Care Access, 2024 Elections May See Voters Demand Affordability
May 15th 2024At the spring conference of the New Jersey Health Care Quality Institute, speakers discussed how health policy, affordability, and transparency may play a role in voters’ decisions.
Read More